Homeowners Insurance Up 33%

 I just received a notice from State Farm that they will be increasing my home insurance by 33% starting July 1, 2026. That adds $48.81 to my monthly premium. Back in 2023 the monthly premium was $104. The new rate for this year is a 90% increase in just 4 years. The home has not had any major renovations since it was purchased in 2011. The county estimates the value for tax purposes at $356,400. Zillow has $397,900 as the estimated market value.

It now costs $512 per month or $6144 per year for insurance and property tax. This year I will get an 80% state refund on my property tax. That will bring the annual cost down to $3083. Unfortunately, the only way to reduce the insurance premium is to find an insurance company with lower rates. Every time they raise my rates, I revisit the idea of getting quotes from other insurance providers. This year the rate increase is way beyond the rate of inflation. I suspect State Farm has been paying out more claims than usual and has decided to increase rates to compensate. Inflation is only a small part of the calculation.

I'm getting tired of State Farm's advertising campaigns anyway. They spent a lot of money on their Batman/Bateman ads. Their main ad character is a black guy. I don't feel like they want me (a white guy) as a customer anymore. Here is a list of 10 well known home/auto insurance companies:

State Farm - The largest share (12.9%) of business in America.

Liberty Mutual - One of the largest property and casualty writers in the world.

Geico (Berkshire) - One of the largest auto insurance providers in the US.

Farmers Insurance - The business dates back to 1928, when it was set up to insure farmers.

Progressive Group - Reputation for pricing innovation and digital tools.

USAA Group - Low auto insurance premiums for qualifying military families.

Allstate Insurance - Recognized for its long‑running "You're in Good Hands" slogan.

Travelers Group - Ranks among the top five companies by market share in US.

American Family - AmFam has a long history in farm and rural markets.

The Hartford (AARP) - Discounted rates exclusively for AARP members.

Of these companies I would only consider getting quotes from Liberty Mutual, Farmers, and USAA. The others just don't have ad campaigns that appeal to me. But what about the Geico gecko and Flo the Progressive lady? They are just a little too comical for me when it comes to insurance. I will report back if I find a better rate. Not sure if that is possible. Something tells me that none of them can be trusted to keep premiums at a reasonable rate for very long.